The Adventure of the Bloody Tower: Dr. John H. Watson’s First Case by Donald MacLachlan
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
The question of who murdered the Princes in the Tower (Edward V and his younger brother, Richard) has puzzled historians for centuries. Richard III, their uncle, has long been the leading suspect for those murders. In an interesting twist on the puzzle, the author has decided that Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson should try and solve it. It then becomes Dr. Watson’s first case to solve on his own.
The author is a gifted writer and endeavors to emulate the tone of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s books while creating an individual voice of his own. Dr. Watson comes across convincingly as an earnest and intelligent man, a bit unsure of himself in this academic environment, but wanting to solve the mystery. Sherlock Holmes does not play a significant role in the book and comes across as a kinder, better friend than he does in Conan Doyle’s books.
The historical mystery itself is well researched, and the author does an impressive job being as even-handed regarding the evidence as possible.
The book flows well, and Richard III buffs will enjoy the historical analysis. I am looking forward to Dr. Watson’s second case!